--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A Community Called Atonement: Living Theology
by Scot McKnight
Edition: Paperback
Price: $12.24
Availability: In Stock
35 used & new from $8.98
a synthetic approach in understanding the atonement, April 12, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: A Community Called Atonement: Living Theology (Paperback)
I appreciate Mcknight's synthetic approach to understanding the atonement in the light of the contemporary discussions that often tend towards polarization and the hardening of categories. The various theories or metaphors are discussed in a concise way - satisfaction, ransom, penal substitution, representation, moral example, Christus Victor, recapitulation and so on - showing the inadequacies of each model as well as its strengths and contributions and how we need to hold them together for a more balanced and holistic view of the death and resurrection of Christ. It augurs well with the Emerging Churches' ethos of generous orthodoxy, which seeks to embrace rather than exclude a diversity of viewpoints in Christian faith and practices. In taking this approach, the church can thus find its way towards charity and unity of faith as well as a more humble, mature and fuller grasp of the mystery, that is the atonement. He devotes several chapters towards the end to fleshing out the outworking of such a synthetic approach and how it could shape the church in her mission, fellowship, worship and work of justice.
I reckon that the book will be useful to one has already entered the contemporary discussion of the atonement for some time and is trying to make sense of the various approaches and theories but will probably prove a little daunting to a new reader who is just getting acquainted with the subject and its historical understandings. Mcknight skilfully steers us away from the slanted portrayals of those theories which have come under fire in some circles and provides us with a more nuanced picture of them, especially the penal substitutionary theory. Some readers might be tempted to charge him for going out of his way to agree with these positions (which he does not really buy, if pressed) for the sake of diplomacy. I doubt this critique is fair and would like Mcknight and synthetic thinkers like him to continue to expand on this work and thereby demonstrate more fully from Scripture and good theology how we do really need 'all the clubs in one bag'. I think even if one goes away disagreeing, one stands to benefit from the charity, humility and even-handedness that characterizes the spirit with which he writes. Comment | Permalink
Your tags:
(Edit) (Add|Edit) (What's this?)
Click to Add: emergentemergent, theologytheology, emerging churchemerging church, atonementatonement, scot mcknightscot mcknight, churchchurch, christianitychristianity, catholiccatholic
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To Love as God Loves
by Roberta C. Bondi
Edition: Paperback
Price: $13.50
Availability: In Stock
28 used & new from $7.17
a simple, reflective companion to reading the desert fathers, April 11, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: To Love as God Loves (Paperback)
This is a short, simple companion to reading the desert fathers. Because the historical and cultural chasm that separates us from the desert fathers/mothers tradition, some of their practices and sayings can sound rather strange and bizzare. Bondi writes as an old friend to the tradition and gives some pointers to anyone with an open mind and heart to receive the gems of these ancient spiritual masters. Bondi advises us against absolutizing the desert fathers' sayings but instead to capture the essence of what they are driving at in some of their rather sometimes shocking statements. For example, the saying 'one hour of sleep a day is enough for the monk who is a fighter' probably goes against the basic rule of modern sleep hygiene. But, taken in context, it is aimed at subduing the body's many compulsions and indulgence so that the will is set free to love.
Indeed, the whole end of the desert fathers' many seemingly superhuman feats is not how far they can stretch their mortal bodies beyond normal breaking points but love. Hence, humility remains the main foundational virtue upon which the whole spiritual quest is built. It is really not in the heroic acts and death-defying stunts where love is nurtured but in the day-to-day small acts of service, hospitality and kindness.
The imagery of the sailboat is a helpful illustration of how the divine and the human come together in a beautiful synergy in the life of sanctification. Human efforts are like the steering of the sail whereas it is the powerful wind of God's grace that propels the boat forward. No desert fathers ever thought that one can make it on his own without the grace of God. Yet, few realize more than they the place of human co-operation and indeed struggles in the economy of real spiritual growth. Hence, even the murderer does not lie beyond the possibility of redemption in so far as he has the ability to cry out 'God, help me!' and yes, 'God has more pity on the murderer struggling to turn his heart and face to God than the thoughtless monk.'(loose paraphrase)
As for the approach to sanctification, Bondi identifies at least two prongs: the subduing of the 'passions' (understood here as the excessive and inordinate desires of the flesh) and a life of prayer. The discussion of the passions is done by giving a brief treatment of the classical seven deadly sins. Prayer is dealt with in the forms of the apophatic tradition - the wordless, imageless prayer of quiet - and the kataphatic tradition - using the psalms, a question, or imagery that reshapes our vision of God around biblical themes.
Overall, a short, easy companion that offers one helpful perspective and approach to harnessing the wisdom of the desert fathers, whose life's quest is to love as God does.
Comment | Permalink
Your tags:
(Edit) (Add|Edit) (What's this?)
Click to Add: christianitychristianity, religion and spiritualityreligion and spirituality, religionreligion, early churchearly church, early church historyearly church history, christian livingchristian living, self-helpself-help, self helpself help, catholiccatholic
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mandate to Difference: An Invitation to the Contemporary Church
by Walter Brueggemann
Edition: Paperback
Price: $14.96
Availability: In Stock
42 used & new from $8.98
poignant, subversive and biblical., March 28, 2010
This review is from: Mandate to Difference: An Invitation to the Contemporary Church (Paperback)
Walter Brueggemann is not capable of writing a boring sentence. His words are well crafted, sharp and provocative, even if different readers will take issues with him on different points. Here is a scholar whose mind has been baptised with decades of deep study and reflection of the biblical materials; it is hard to pull apart the exegetical basis of his proposals, which are often subversive to contemporary habits of thoughts.
This collection of talks he gave on different occasions to the contemporary audience, brings the ancient texts of Scriptures to bear on the modern church, primarily in the American socio-political context but in many ways relevant to other modern societies as well. He basically circles around the theme of God's alternative society vs Pharaoh's/Philistine's/Caesar's empire. Hence it is God's life-giving command of the Sabbath against the quota-system of the urban world, God's invitation to rest in his abundant grace vs the harried and hurried quest for acquisition, consumptions and accomplishments that bolster the idolatrous self. Here, he unmasks the illusions of human greed and proposes instead a life centered around God and neighbour and that liberates the self for shalom - for art, beauty and play.
Being very much a part of the Pharaohic world myself, I have to take the leisurely pace to digest this book and hear the message it is intended to convey. Thankfully, Brueggemann is as much a poet as he is a careful scholar;his words have a way of stretching your imagination, evoking an alternative world and holding out hope for a world starving for a fresh script with which to order its existence. Most of us know that business as usual simply will not do. I thank God for Brueggemann who helps us to listen to the ancient texts again that are capable of speaking afresh to every generation in such a powerful and liberating way. Comment | Permalink
Your tags:
(Edit) (Add|Edit) (What's this?)
Click to Add: christianitychristianity, brueggemannbrueggemann, walter brueggemannwalter brueggemann, pentecostalpentecostal, walterwalter, charismaticcharismatic, old testamentold testament, catholiccatholic
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Ascent to Truth
by Thomas Merton
Edition: Paperback
Price: $10.20
Availability: In Stock
43 used & new from $1.85
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Merton's reading of John of the Cross - reason in the contemplative life, November 19, 2009
This review is from: The Ascent to Truth (Paperback)
The mystical literature of John of the Cross is known for its literary beauty and spiritual profundity but it is not always accessible. The Ascent to Truth is a clear and reliable guide to understanding him. Merton's Catholic and monastic background together with his literary gifts makes him an excellent expositor of St John. Merton devotes many pages to exploring the place of reason (understood here as spiritual discernment, good sense/moderation and biblical understanding) in the mystical life. This is a helpful corrective to tendencies of some readers of John and practitioners of contemplative prayers that elevate personal experiences over the intellect, almost treating the latter as a hindrance to be bypassed. While recognising the immediacy of mystical union and the passivity of the natural faculties when one is graced with infused contemplation, one never at any point dispenses with the need to stay rooted in the concreteness of the revealed word of God and in Christ. That is to say, a sound grasp of biblical truths is essential in preparing one to receive by faith a deeper apprehension of divine mysteries that go beyond the intellect itself as one reaches out to God in love.
Besides John of the Cross, Merton also draws lessons from the other great spiritual teachers such as John Ruysbroek, Teresa of Avila, Gregory of Nyssa and others that have left us some signposts along the mystical path that help one discern where one might be in the journey, avoid some of the pitfalls and know when one is ready to advance. Though the book gets tedious at times in its seemingly repetitive circling around the book's main theme - reason in the life of contemplation, Merton delights us with some fine touches every now and then such as these:
'Contemplation is one of the indications of spiritual maturity. It is closely allied to sanctity. You cannot save the world merely with a system. You cannot have peace without charity. You cannot have order without saints. Our nature imposes on us a pattern of development which we must follow if we are to fulfil our best capacities and achieve at least the partial happiness of being human. The pattern must be understood and worked out in all its essential elements. But it can be stated very simply: We must know the truth, and we must love the truth we know, and we must act according to the measure of our love.' (pg 8)
'All the deeper instincts of a true theologian warned Saint John of the Cross that the revealed word of God offered him greater security than did experience itself, where there was question of a supernatural order in which the ways were known with certitude by Him alone who had established them.' (pg 124) Comment | Permalink
Sunday, September 12, 2010
Amazon Book Reviews 6
vision of worship with an eschatological focus, September 6, 2010
Ben Witherington with his characteristic way with words brings his expert NT knowledge on the subject of worship. This is a comparatively short book compared to the many academic tomes this prolific writer has churned out. It is probably targeted at the thoughtful Christian readers who sit in the pew wondering what the bible has to say about worship, given that worship cannot simply be a habit shaped by one's church tradition and the secular culture rather than what God has said about it. Witherington has some sharp things to say about Christians caught up in the 'what's in it for me?' culture of our time because he contends that worship is about God's glory rather than ours and more of what we do in response to his worth than what we hope to get out of the transaction. On another prong, he challenges the slavish carryover of Judaic practices such as Sabbath, priesthood, sacrifices and temple into Christian worship. While he notes the continuity with the old covenant, he puts the emphasis on the discontinuity as a result of what Christ has fulfilled through his life, death and resurrection. He therefore restores the Christ event to the center of Christian worship.
The Christ event does not simply call for a backward look into the past but calls us forward to the heavenly worship pictured in Rev 4-5. Our worship ought to recognise the inbreaking of God's kingdom with the first Easter as well as the advanced taste of worship in the new cosmos following the final Easter. This helps situates Christian worship in the proper place within the larger salvation historical narrative.
Witherington fleshes out this eschatological focus of worship by taking us through various NT texts that deal with the various components of Christian worship - preparing to be caught up in the Spirit on the Lord's Day, preaching, singing, the Lord's Supper, the Lord's Prayer and the labors of love. In reading this book, one gets the message that much of what gets passed for worship today suffers from some serious deficits - the narcissism, the shallow theological content, the disconnect between worship and life- to name just a few. This is therefore an important contribution to educating pastors, worship planners/leaders and all the people of God participating in worship. The discussion questions appended to each chapter will be useful for small group study.
If worship is the chief end of human existence, then Witherington's call to re-examine and reform our service to God in the light of scripture is an important one. But he does more than call. He has given us this basic primer with which to start exploring what it means to truly worship in the Spirit and in truth.
My only criticism is that it could be better organised around some logical structure or familiar liturgical movements. I find myself bogged down quite easily by the disparate concerns of the selected passages (as it is the nature of the NT materials to be occasion-based). This leads to the unfortunate glossing over of the Lord's Supper, which was strangely subsumed as a small subsection under the chapter devoted to talking about the sermon. In fact, if there is one place where eschatology should come to a sharp focus, it would be the Eucharist! Notwithstanding this flaw, Witherington's textual expositions are as in many of his commentary writings solid and inspiring. But readers need to keep in mind the overarching theme of eschatological worship to avoid getting lost in the interesting bits.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pilgrim Heart: The Way of Jesus in Everyday Life
by Darryl Tippens
Edition: Paperback
Price: $10.19
Availability: In Stock
56 used & new from $0.11
a helpful retreat companion, September 5, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Pilgrim Heart: The Way of Jesus in Everyday Life (Paperback)
I find this book to be a good guide to soul care.. to be put alongside books like 'Keeping the Sabbath Holy' (Dawn) and 'Testament of Devotion'(Kelly). The gentle, conversational tone immediately puts you in the state to receive soul food, soul care and rest. Indeed, in my own frantic world of speed, tight schedule and demands, this is a welcome reminder to slow down and take ourselves a little less seriously and let God be God. For example, I took his suggestion to sometimes take the slowest lane to deliberately drive at a lower gear! Tippens suggests helpful way to prevent the rigor of discipleship and vocation from becoming anemic for the lack of space and time to receive the fresh dews of God's nourishment through the practices of spiritual reading, hospitality, forgiveness, music, art, story-telling and rest. It is still a difficult discipline for me despite the number of very good materials I've read on the subject. The balance between work and rest remains a delicate one to maintain. But Tippens has a knack of slowing you down with every page and opening up a space amidst the clutter so we can breathe deep from the eternal source of life. It is however a different kind of book than what i thought the title suggests. Not exactly 'the way of Jesus in everyday life' as in the way of cross bearing and discipleship rigor but surely a helpful retreat companion for every serious Christ-follower who will benefit from a timely reminder to take breaks, care for one's own heart, travel light and enjoy the journey. For the weary, struggling, hurting and beleaguered pilgrims, Tippens has written a balm full of gentle wisdom.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Forgive and Forget: Healing the Hurts We Don't Deserve (Plus)
by Lewis B. Smedes
Edition: Paperback
Price: $10.07
best book on forgiveness!, September 2, 2010
This review is from: Forgive and Forget: Healing the Hurts We Don't Deserve (Plus) (Paperback)
This is the best book I've ever read on the subject of 'forgiveness'. It is written with wit, biblical wisdom, practicality and compassion. It first disabuses you of all the caricatures of what forgiveness is - excusing, tolerating, condoning, etc. Then, as usual, Smedes comes at the subject with his typical hard-nosed treatment. In forgiving someone, the sin has to be grappled with for what it is - wrong, unfair, evil and hurtful. One should not simply gloss over and get over it but take it into account, experience deeply the horrendous evil that it is and call it to curse. It is in confronting sin as it is and coming to grips with the the deep hurts that it brings, that one could ever go on to slowly let go of the associated onslaught of anger and resentment. It is a long journey for most and one might have to forgive the same sin by the same person over and over again. One comes to know that forgiveness is beginning to bear fruit when one begins to see the adversary with new ('magic') eyes and the event of the hurt with a new perspective that sets one's heart free to love. While the goal of forgiveness includes the healing of the aggrieved, it also opens up the real possibility of reconciliation. But Smedes wisely cautions that reconciliation takes two parties and on this side of eternity, forgiveness needs not hang on reconciliation for its completion. This is as realistic as one can get.
In recent years, Smedes has been criticised for operating too much under the therapeutic mode and falls short of the reconciliation aimed at by the biblical ideals by such books as 'Embodying Forgiveness' by Gregory Jones. While the latter is a fine book to be read profitably in its own right, its critique of Smedes is in my reading wide off the mark. Smedes was charged as advocating a kind of forgiveness that is aimed primarily at healing the individual's hurts and ignoring the larger issues of sins, culpability, repentance and reconciliation. I think given Smedes' more modest aim in focusing on the discipline and experience of forgiveness in this book, he has simply been criticised for not writing beyond the scope of what he intends to focus on.I think this book should simply be taken on its own merits. One has to read it to see that Smedes writes not only with academic precision but also hard-won compassion culled from the tough work of forgiving your debtors in this broken world. It is an immensely liberating and life-transforming work!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discovering Biblical Equality: Complementarity Without Hierarchy
by Ronald W. Pierce
Edition: Paperback
Price: $19.80
Availability: In Stock
23 used & new from $14.00
Currently the best one-volume compilation of essays on gender-egalitarianism, September 2, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Discovering Biblical Equality: Complementarity Without Hierarchy (Paperback)
This, I submit, is probably the best one-volume compilation of essays contending for gender equality and complementarity (what has come under the label of 'egalitarianism') currently available. It is a concerted scholarly response to the 'complementarian' counterpart 'Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood' that apparently does not, IMHO, quite enjoy the level of erudition that this book presents from a plethora of leading evangelical scholars such as Gordon Fee, Craig Keener, Howard Marshall and Stanley Grenz. I especially enjoy, though not necessarily endorsing its conclusion, the article by Rebecca Groothuis "Equal in Being; Unequal in Role", which of course challenges the notion that the genders can be essentially equal and yet functionally unequal. To me, this grasps exactly the nettle whereby egalitarianism and complementarianism part ways. She argues that the supposed paradox is a red herring since the so-called 'functional hierarchy' is maintained (permanently) on the basis of gender, that is the nature/essence of being a man or woman and hence cannot be compatible with equality in being.
I am also convinced that the popular label 'complementarianism' by which the opposing camp would like to be identified with is a facade for what is really gender hierarchichalism albeit in function, because at the heart of its position is a belief in male authority (over the woman), however one softens it with concepts like 'servant leadership', 'honor of headship', 'accountability', or 'shepherding', etc. On the other hand, the egalitarian contenders are really arguing for gender *complementarity*, the kind that does away with any notion of hierarchy or authority on the basis of one's gender; it is not simply advocating equality per se, which is often confused with identity/undifferentiation. Perhaps, the revision of the respective labels is an essential first step in clearing the confusion and maintaining the integrity of what each position is really pitching for. Both views in fact advocate complementarity; the difference is that one has the principle of male functional authority worked into it and the other does not.
This book is a pleasure to read for the gracious and intelligent way in which the egalitarian (ie. complementarity without hierarchy) view is laid out from a wide variety of angles. However, for all its erudition and scholarly work in exegesis, it still remains to be seen if it has produced a persuasive case against what seems to be derived from the 'plain sense of the texts', esp in Paul (1 Cor 11, 14, Eph 5, 1 Tim 2) which appear at face value to support male headship rooted in the intent of the Creator and perhaps even the nature of the economic Trinity(?), however 'incoherent' it may seem to our modern minds. Hence, the issue remains open for me and perhaps will remain so for a long time to come. In the mean time, the old adage is ever so relevant: 'unity in essentials, liberty in adiaphora and charity in all things!'
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mere Discipleship: Radical Christianity in a Rebellious World
by Lee C. Camp
Edition: Paperback
Price: $14.95
Availability: In Stock
31 used & new from $8.00
an anabaptist vision already championed by not a few writers, September 2, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Mere Discipleship: Radical Christianity in a Rebellious World (Paperback)
I appreciate Lee Camp's contribution to the wider discourse of what Christian faith can and ought to be in contrast to the 'Constantinian' version in American Christianity. I was able to read through it fairly quickly, recognising most of it as a re-presenting of ideas readers of Yoder, Hauerwas, Clapp and Boyd would have been familiar with. In fact, a lot of the syntaxes and terms (even the provocative jargon!) are borrowed from these other writers as much as the concepts themselves. So while there is much in this proposal there is attractive in light of the hijack of the Christian gospel in the interest of a certain brand of American religio- politics, I am left somewhat disappointed when i lay the book down and wondering if an heir-theologian of the Stone-Campbell tradition has something more original to bring to the table even if it were a nuanced distillation of what one has learned from his mentor. It sounds too much like an echo of a lot of what these other thinkers have already said. I would recommend instead the works of Leonard Allen and John Mark Hicks for a more creative voice to come out of 'America's best kept secret', as Scot Mcknight called it - the Churches of Christ. Having said that, I can see how such a book could be helpful to Christians across the board who long for a more radical expression of the Christian faith though I suspect that a pacifist, anti-Constantinian, contra-Niebuhrian paradigm needs not be the only way of going about it. In this respect, John Stackhouse's Christian Realism articulated in his book 'Making the Best of It' could be a refreshing take in its own right.
Ben Witherington with his characteristic way with words brings his expert NT knowledge on the subject of worship. This is a comparatively short book compared to the many academic tomes this prolific writer has churned out. It is probably targeted at the thoughtful Christian readers who sit in the pew wondering what the bible has to say about worship, given that worship cannot simply be a habit shaped by one's church tradition and the secular culture rather than what God has said about it. Witherington has some sharp things to say about Christians caught up in the 'what's in it for me?' culture of our time because he contends that worship is about God's glory rather than ours and more of what we do in response to his worth than what we hope to get out of the transaction. On another prong, he challenges the slavish carryover of Judaic practices such as Sabbath, priesthood, sacrifices and temple into Christian worship. While he notes the continuity with the old covenant, he puts the emphasis on the discontinuity as a result of what Christ has fulfilled through his life, death and resurrection. He therefore restores the Christ event to the center of Christian worship.
The Christ event does not simply call for a backward look into the past but calls us forward to the heavenly worship pictured in Rev 4-5. Our worship ought to recognise the inbreaking of God's kingdom with the first Easter as well as the advanced taste of worship in the new cosmos following the final Easter. This helps situates Christian worship in the proper place within the larger salvation historical narrative.
Witherington fleshes out this eschatological focus of worship by taking us through various NT texts that deal with the various components of Christian worship - preparing to be caught up in the Spirit on the Lord's Day, preaching, singing, the Lord's Supper, the Lord's Prayer and the labors of love. In reading this book, one gets the message that much of what gets passed for worship today suffers from some serious deficits - the narcissism, the shallow theological content, the disconnect between worship and life- to name just a few. This is therefore an important contribution to educating pastors, worship planners/leaders and all the people of God participating in worship. The discussion questions appended to each chapter will be useful for small group study.
If worship is the chief end of human existence, then Witherington's call to re-examine and reform our service to God in the light of scripture is an important one. But he does more than call. He has given us this basic primer with which to start exploring what it means to truly worship in the Spirit and in truth.
My only criticism is that it could be better organised around some logical structure or familiar liturgical movements. I find myself bogged down quite easily by the disparate concerns of the selected passages (as it is the nature of the NT materials to be occasion-based). This leads to the unfortunate glossing over of the Lord's Supper, which was strangely subsumed as a small subsection under the chapter devoted to talking about the sermon. In fact, if there is one place where eschatology should come to a sharp focus, it would be the Eucharist! Notwithstanding this flaw, Witherington's textual expositions are as in many of his commentary writings solid and inspiring. But readers need to keep in mind the overarching theme of eschatological worship to avoid getting lost in the interesting bits.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pilgrim Heart: The Way of Jesus in Everyday Life
by Darryl Tippens
Edition: Paperback
Price: $10.19
Availability: In Stock
56 used & new from $0.11
a helpful retreat companion, September 5, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Pilgrim Heart: The Way of Jesus in Everyday Life (Paperback)
I find this book to be a good guide to soul care.. to be put alongside books like 'Keeping the Sabbath Holy' (Dawn) and 'Testament of Devotion'(Kelly). The gentle, conversational tone immediately puts you in the state to receive soul food, soul care and rest. Indeed, in my own frantic world of speed, tight schedule and demands, this is a welcome reminder to slow down and take ourselves a little less seriously and let God be God. For example, I took his suggestion to sometimes take the slowest lane to deliberately drive at a lower gear! Tippens suggests helpful way to prevent the rigor of discipleship and vocation from becoming anemic for the lack of space and time to receive the fresh dews of God's nourishment through the practices of spiritual reading, hospitality, forgiveness, music, art, story-telling and rest. It is still a difficult discipline for me despite the number of very good materials I've read on the subject. The balance between work and rest remains a delicate one to maintain. But Tippens has a knack of slowing you down with every page and opening up a space amidst the clutter so we can breathe deep from the eternal source of life. It is however a different kind of book than what i thought the title suggests. Not exactly 'the way of Jesus in everyday life' as in the way of cross bearing and discipleship rigor but surely a helpful retreat companion for every serious Christ-follower who will benefit from a timely reminder to take breaks, care for one's own heart, travel light and enjoy the journey. For the weary, struggling, hurting and beleaguered pilgrims, Tippens has written a balm full of gentle wisdom.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Forgive and Forget: Healing the Hurts We Don't Deserve (Plus)
by Lewis B. Smedes
Edition: Paperback
Price: $10.07
best book on forgiveness!, September 2, 2010
This review is from: Forgive and Forget: Healing the Hurts We Don't Deserve (Plus) (Paperback)
This is the best book I've ever read on the subject of 'forgiveness'. It is written with wit, biblical wisdom, practicality and compassion. It first disabuses you of all the caricatures of what forgiveness is - excusing, tolerating, condoning, etc. Then, as usual, Smedes comes at the subject with his typical hard-nosed treatment. In forgiving someone, the sin has to be grappled with for what it is - wrong, unfair, evil and hurtful. One should not simply gloss over and get over it but take it into account, experience deeply the horrendous evil that it is and call it to curse. It is in confronting sin as it is and coming to grips with the the deep hurts that it brings, that one could ever go on to slowly let go of the associated onslaught of anger and resentment. It is a long journey for most and one might have to forgive the same sin by the same person over and over again. One comes to know that forgiveness is beginning to bear fruit when one begins to see the adversary with new ('magic') eyes and the event of the hurt with a new perspective that sets one's heart free to love. While the goal of forgiveness includes the healing of the aggrieved, it also opens up the real possibility of reconciliation. But Smedes wisely cautions that reconciliation takes two parties and on this side of eternity, forgiveness needs not hang on reconciliation for its completion. This is as realistic as one can get.
In recent years, Smedes has been criticised for operating too much under the therapeutic mode and falls short of the reconciliation aimed at by the biblical ideals by such books as 'Embodying Forgiveness' by Gregory Jones. While the latter is a fine book to be read profitably in its own right, its critique of Smedes is in my reading wide off the mark. Smedes was charged as advocating a kind of forgiveness that is aimed primarily at healing the individual's hurts and ignoring the larger issues of sins, culpability, repentance and reconciliation. I think given Smedes' more modest aim in focusing on the discipline and experience of forgiveness in this book, he has simply been criticised for not writing beyond the scope of what he intends to focus on.I think this book should simply be taken on its own merits. One has to read it to see that Smedes writes not only with academic precision but also hard-won compassion culled from the tough work of forgiving your debtors in this broken world. It is an immensely liberating and life-transforming work!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Discovering Biblical Equality: Complementarity Without Hierarchy
by Ronald W. Pierce
Edition: Paperback
Price: $19.80
Availability: In Stock
23 used & new from $14.00
Currently the best one-volume compilation of essays on gender-egalitarianism, September 2, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Discovering Biblical Equality: Complementarity Without Hierarchy (Paperback)
This, I submit, is probably the best one-volume compilation of essays contending for gender equality and complementarity (what has come under the label of 'egalitarianism') currently available. It is a concerted scholarly response to the 'complementarian' counterpart 'Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood' that apparently does not, IMHO, quite enjoy the level of erudition that this book presents from a plethora of leading evangelical scholars such as Gordon Fee, Craig Keener, Howard Marshall and Stanley Grenz. I especially enjoy, though not necessarily endorsing its conclusion, the article by Rebecca Groothuis "Equal in Being; Unequal in Role", which of course challenges the notion that the genders can be essentially equal and yet functionally unequal. To me, this grasps exactly the nettle whereby egalitarianism and complementarianism part ways. She argues that the supposed paradox is a red herring since the so-called 'functional hierarchy' is maintained (permanently) on the basis of gender, that is the nature/essence of being a man or woman and hence cannot be compatible with equality in being.
I am also convinced that the popular label 'complementarianism' by which the opposing camp would like to be identified with is a facade for what is really gender hierarchichalism albeit in function, because at the heart of its position is a belief in male authority (over the woman), however one softens it with concepts like 'servant leadership', 'honor of headship', 'accountability', or 'shepherding', etc. On the other hand, the egalitarian contenders are really arguing for gender *complementarity*, the kind that does away with any notion of hierarchy or authority on the basis of one's gender; it is not simply advocating equality per se, which is often confused with identity/undifferentiation. Perhaps, the revision of the respective labels is an essential first step in clearing the confusion and maintaining the integrity of what each position is really pitching for. Both views in fact advocate complementarity; the difference is that one has the principle of male functional authority worked into it and the other does not.
This book is a pleasure to read for the gracious and intelligent way in which the egalitarian (ie. complementarity without hierarchy) view is laid out from a wide variety of angles. However, for all its erudition and scholarly work in exegesis, it still remains to be seen if it has produced a persuasive case against what seems to be derived from the 'plain sense of the texts', esp in Paul (1 Cor 11, 14, Eph 5, 1 Tim 2) which appear at face value to support male headship rooted in the intent of the Creator and perhaps even the nature of the economic Trinity(?), however 'incoherent' it may seem to our modern minds. Hence, the issue remains open for me and perhaps will remain so for a long time to come. In the mean time, the old adage is ever so relevant: 'unity in essentials, liberty in adiaphora and charity in all things!'
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mere Discipleship: Radical Christianity in a Rebellious World
by Lee C. Camp
Edition: Paperback
Price: $14.95
Availability: In Stock
31 used & new from $8.00
an anabaptist vision already championed by not a few writers, September 2, 2010
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Mere Discipleship: Radical Christianity in a Rebellious World (Paperback)
I appreciate Lee Camp's contribution to the wider discourse of what Christian faith can and ought to be in contrast to the 'Constantinian' version in American Christianity. I was able to read through it fairly quickly, recognising most of it as a re-presenting of ideas readers of Yoder, Hauerwas, Clapp and Boyd would have been familiar with. In fact, a lot of the syntaxes and terms (even the provocative jargon!) are borrowed from these other writers as much as the concepts themselves. So while there is much in this proposal there is attractive in light of the hijack of the Christian gospel in the interest of a certain brand of American religio- politics, I am left somewhat disappointed when i lay the book down and wondering if an heir-theologian of the Stone-Campbell tradition has something more original to bring to the table even if it were a nuanced distillation of what one has learned from his mentor. It sounds too much like an echo of a lot of what these other thinkers have already said. I would recommend instead the works of Leonard Allen and John Mark Hicks for a more creative voice to come out of 'America's best kept secret', as Scot Mcknight called it - the Churches of Christ. Having said that, I can see how such a book could be helpful to Christians across the board who long for a more radical expression of the Christian faith though I suspect that a pacifist, anti-Constantinian, contra-Niebuhrian paradigm needs not be the only way of going about it. In this respect, John Stackhouse's Christian Realism articulated in his book 'Making the Best of It' could be a refreshing take in its own right.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)